Tried first start on the Pinto today and it looks like the starter motor doesn't have enough grunt to turn over the engine, you can see the fly wheel kick a little bit when it engages but it won't turn over. I got the starter second hand, when you put the power to it off the engine it sounds good and spins really fast. The engine turns over by hand its tight I have to use bar on the pulley to turn it but I would've expected that.
What do I try next?